My only rule is you have to post the same amount for each to keep it fair. You can also post something other than a model like a type of content or clip style.

Overrated:
Violet James - Killer body, just an overwhelmingly massive slab of fat, but I think her videos are so repetitive. Just years and years of endless monotone fat chats and the same belly rub. The dynamic she had with Ivy was awesome but she got boring when she went out on her own. Never even showed her tits if I remember correctly.

Mochii - More of a circus sideshow than a fetish model. She's not particularly attractive, has zero charisma on camera, and frankly isn't even THAT fat. Yes it was amusing watching her speedrun her health into the ground but beyond that I never got her appeal and I don't know what her fans on here are still holding on to.

Lady Sublime - Ugh, this one brings me no pleasure. She's perfect on paper - 6 feet tall, 500 pounds (I think she embellishes the weight a bit but I'm willing to play ball), hotter than hell, well-spoken. And yet her content bores me to tears; she's almost too icy and composed for me, like everything she says is super rehearsed.

Underrated:
Cookie BBW - Something about this girl drives me absolutely wild lol. The girl next door vibe, her cute little accent, massive voluptuous curves. There's something candid and down to earth about her content, like she's giving you a secret glimpse into the pervy shit she does behind closed doors. There's something deeply erotic about a woman who looks like she holds down an office job when she's not busy stuffing herself to the brim with pizza and masturbating on camera.

Pleasantly Plump - I think she gets some credit but not nearly enough IMO. One of my favorite blob girls ever and a rare case of someone who sells the shit out of the extreme weight gain fantasy; I'm aware she was a real deal phone sex operator at one point so she may just be a good actress, but I always got the sense she enjoyed what she was doing. That goes a long way for me. Also looks hot as hell wearing a pig nose which is not usually my thing, but if the shoe fits...

Sasha - I think the tide is finally turning for Sasha since a lot of her peers have slowed down or retired, but I want to give the girl her flowers. She's been quietly pumping out great, varied content for years, all while doubling her body weight, keeping OF and clip prices reasonable and being generally accessible to fans - I've been in some of her livestreams and they're always a blast. Plus have you seen her?? She looks better now than when she was in her 20s. The only real knock on her is she didn't come into her own until leaving Big Cuties, but you could say that for a lot of models.

>>89414 (OP)
I've gotta admit, that's a scorching hot take on Lady Sublime

What you're describing is called poise and it's desperately lacking in this fetish

I disagree with you on a visceral level but I respect the level of iconoclasm on display here

>>89422
Completely valid point. I guess I just prefer my stuff to feel a bit more raw and off the cuff.

>>89448
Lady Sublime just does a ton of roleplay vids instead of being "herself" (which I know can be a dubious prospect in this scene but you know what I mean). I can't call her overrated because when she does the rare naturalistic vid, it's A++ and it's not like she doesn't still look insane in vids where the subject matter isn't as interesting to me. But I get the OPs point here, especially since a bright, likable woman who used to be a fairly lanky, mainstream hot chick gaining 300 pounds over the years is so sexy and unusual that she doesn't need roles or characters all the time. Just regular fat chat/funny story about being a quarter ton Amazon out in the world kind of vids would be great.

I'd call Lady Sublime *underrated* by sheer virtue of her ludicrous sexiness and gain from where she started as a 200-pound cammer while also agreeing with the above about her content. She's still the ideal for the fetish imo, a one in a billion kind of gainer even if the content choices themselves are a little, yeah, scripted.

>>89458
She is absolutely sublime

no pics
0/10 thread
would not reply

>>89478
Can’t stand her face.
She looks like project managers at work, the kind who flirt with men in their 50s.

>>89486
Well, if you're going to have a terrible take, you at least made it bizarrely specific.

>>89486
You say this like it's a bad thing.

>>89456
You summed it up much better than I could. Perhaps I’ll seek out some of her more naturalistic videos.

>>89530
The recent diet and exercise vids on her site were really surprising because it's just her doing fat chat, totally down to earth and really sexy.

Overrated:
myfatblondegf: I made a thread about a month ago on models you plainly just don't like, and I used myfatblondegf as an example. I find her to look entirely stupid, like she's an unintelligent, disabled woman. Her entire demeanor consists of opening her mouth and puffing out her double chin to exagerrated degrees. She makes a mess of herself anytime she does some eating thing, of which eating tends to be downright comedic.
CurvyPochi: I hate when models look "lumpy", or when their fat kind of just corral into one area. She had this strange ball-belly and uneven chest that wasn't attractive to me. Her facial expressions also were just quite unsexy to me.
CouchQueenie: Lesser than the other two, but I consider her to be very boring and bland. Her facial expressions are boring and she doesn't bother hiding the fakeness of it.
Honorable mention: LonelyGirlTV: I was impressed how beautiful she was, but her demeanor was always... off. She talked in an extremely strange manner, speaking loud for no reason while giving the same boring spiel about how fat she has gotten. Turns out she was a total nutcase and it expressed in her gaining. She's retired.

Underrated:
LittlestPiggletAnn: She's very cute! She's started thin and has gained over the course of some ten years I think. Wish people would check her out more often.
MinaMahal: Very pretty, did some good ASMR videos and generally good content. I think she's retired, though.

>>89414 (OP)
Overrated:

1. Dumplin. She's got a great body and her gain has been impressive, but all the drama she gets involved in and all the spouting off on social media is really annoying

2. LisaLou. Loved her off the bat and her initial gain was very impressive, but it seems like she's gotten really complacent with it. Also I'm all for a good eating/stuffing vid but I feel like she does too many of them and there's not much diversity in her content.

3. Colors of Autumn. Amazing ass but really disappointing that she lost weight and never wanted to show off her belly when she was bigger. Could have been incredible if she had gained weight or even stayed where she was at her heaviest

Underrated:

1. Thick As Honey. Incredible gain, pretty diverse content and seems to be invested in getting fatter. Has a cute face IMO and well-proportioned.

2. Cherries. Pretty face and just an amazing belly. Hasn't been posting as much lately but and says she doesn't gain intentionally but she's slowly been getting bigger.

3. Marilyn. Huge tits, huge belly, pretty face. Gained a ton initially when she started on BigCuties then lost some of it and her content slowed down, but now she's on OF and seems to be gaining again and posting frequently.

>>89544
Dumplin fell into the "authentic" trap - trying to just be herself with no separation between her actual real life self and her brand, and as a result, degrading her brand with her real life stuff. There needs to be a filter there. Boberry does a really good job of appearing and feeling authentic, without actually being her real life self, Lisa does a decent job of it too. One on end of the extreme you have models like Lady Sublime, who is ONLY the brand, with absolutely zero authenticity whatsoever, just cold hard calculated fetish porn. On the other end you have slobs like Chubby Chiquita who is literally just posting as her own self with no concept of brand at all. Dumplin doesn't seem to understand this yet but hopefully she does soon.

I'd push back on your placement of LisaLou and Marilyn - I think they're both accurately rated. Lisa has been posting and gaining consistently, and has earned her place in the upper tiers. Marilyn was gone for what, ten years? Maybe not ten, but several years? And lost a lot of weight too? I think she has a lot of work to do to re-establish herself. But I hope she sticks around this time, gains it all back and then some

>>89545
Good take.

Lisa has been steadily gaining and puts out more content than most girls at that level. She's done 54 full-length/PPV videos since the start of 2025, and 12 of them have been stuffings.

If we want to talk about someone who does too many stuffing videos, you could start with Queen YaaYaa.

>>89545
I don't think Marilyn was ever absent for that long. I think she went through like a 2 year stretch where she was 'active' but rarely updating with BC. And that kind of coincided with the downfall of BC where lots of models were leaving and the ones that stayed were all posting updates very infrequently. But she started on OF in May and she's been posting just about every day, sometimes multiple times a day

>>89414 (OP)
Overrated:
Goddess Shar: Fake dolled up look that makes her look like the (second to Reiina) most plastic surgery addled model on the scene. She has like 50 makeup looks and none of them make her look good enough to make up for the flaws in her content. Her eating videos have so many jump cuts that it's impossible to believe she ate her food in one sitting. Fuck any video that's not her sitting in one unmoving position has so many jump cuts and shitty camera angles that it almost feels like she's trolling her audience and seeing how far she can push it and still profit. One of the few popular models that I have tried to watch repeatedly, and can confidently say has only ever made unwatchable dogshit. Is she as popular as she is just because of her low starting weight? It's the only reason I can fathom but she's not even the only model with a low starting weight and they all make better content than her.

The rest of these probably won't be this autistically long (could've made it longer tbh).

Ero hime: She posits herself as someone who eats a shit ton in her videos, but she makes herself vomit before an average person would say they're full. It's weirdly inconsistent though because she has a handful of videos where she doesn't make herself vomit and actually can put down a large amount of food. Also the undersides of her eyes make her face look a bit weird, but I could look past that one someone with a consistently good stomach capacity.

Ella Eats: She's gaining fast and she's hot, but what little content there is of her is just recorded streams and pirated recorded streams. Imo she's too highly rated for a model who's entire business model is multiple hour long boring livestreams.

Underrated:
Calidoll/Calypsodoll: Consistently eats herself to the point of gagging, eats a lot of food for someone that's only chubby, and you can see a good amount of chub on her frame. Unfortunately she hasn't posted in three weeks and her comments on her last video have retards timestamping an accidental face reveal, so she might move on (hopefully not though).

Little Eater: She puts out one video whenever she needs money, she's skinny and never gains weight, by all accounts she should be utter dogshit... but her fucking stomach capacity is insane. She can eat and eat and eat and you can see the aftereffects clear as day. Weirdly enough, her only making content every few months/years actually makes it better in this singular instance, because either she continues to eat like this in her absences to maintain this stomach capacity, or she doesn't and her stomach's permanently stretched to be able to do this after ages of not practicing. I guess I find medical anomalies sexy.

Stuffy Bunny: People decry her jump cuts and her probably cutting her part 1s and part 2s to be one meal when they're probably 2 meals hours apart behind the scenes, but she eats so much between jump cuts that it's impossible to call her someone who can't put it away. Even if you take into account and assume that her part 1s and part 2s are hours apart AND she's cutting her vids to make it seem like she eats more (and I find it hard to believe the latter happens often), she still eats more than 99% of the models in this fetish easily.

>>89551
I think Lisa is pretty properly rated around here. Her stuff almost always gets posted and she seems well-liked without any of the weird fanaticism or drama that comes with being a popular fat fetish model. Nobody really seems to hate her either.

Anyway I’m prepared to get roasted for this but Jae’s body of work has become weirdly underrated because of her dramatic exit from the scene. If you ignore all that she was a 5’11” bombshell with big tits, a big gut and a big ass who did everything from soft core pinup modeling to cam shows to hardcore with both men and women (her stuff with Brianna is hall of fame pantheon type shit, just two horny behemoth chicks going at it) to squashings and stuffings and weigh ins and roleplays and other fat fetish stuff. Oh and she blew up to near 700 pounds before calling it quits. She basically had no holes in her game except being annoying online and eventually quitting and she’s sure as hell not the only girl to ever do either of those things.

On the overrated side I’m gonna have to go with Echo who I find borderline disturbing to watch. Her content is just feels bizarrely naive and unsexualized and her voice and whole persona are nails on a chalkboard to me. When I’m in the mood for a humongous blob girl I tend to lean towards girls who are slightly more… lucid.

Overrated:

GoddessGlutton: She's chopped as hell and farms femdom.

Skylar: Her content has never been that great (showed zero emotion), she lost weight yet somehow charges more.

Katie Cummings: Only on the list because of how hyped she is. Gets called the GOAT as if she ever liked being fat, reduced her breasts, and will only do feederism content for no less than a New York rent payment.

Underrated:

Big Belly Judy: Huge gain, huge gut, attractive, her stuffings are otherworldly(quantity of food and has puked before) and she makes good content

Eliza Allure: Slept on so much as a feedee. Had an amazing gain, literally does every bit of every genre of content you could ever ask for, and her JOIs are top 5 easy

Caroline Quinn: Easily top 5 most attractive models IMO, and has produced an insane gain. Gets slept on because her stuffings aren't crazy and she makes too much niche.

One of the most underrated models imo is CaitforShort. I’ve only ever seen one of her vids shared, never had her own thread and she’s getting really big.

>>89595
>On the overrated side I’m gonna have to go with Echo
Really? Her nonchalant slice-of-life at 800 lbs content was my favorite. Every USSBBW talks about how hard it is to be that size... except for Echo, who just treats it as a casual part of her life

>>89414 (OP)
>Overrated:
Violet James - Killer body, just an overwhelmingly massive slab of fat...
I dont see where Violet is anywhere near "Overrated" rarely see her getting posted, just once in a goon someoney starts a Thread that dissappears faster than they wank,,,
Anyway, here are my picks:

Overrated:
BoBerry: Shes hot and deserves every attention she gets, but gooners praise her and her Content like its out of this world, even her VIP days, Shit was expensive as fuck for what you got in return... She always seemed like a Kardashian in the SSBBW Secene to me... like gooners would by her "bathwater" if she sold it... still 10/10 Model, just a bit overrated but i can see why

Queenyaayaa: Not many words for here, for me to like a woman in this fetish i need to find her attractive in some way... she just doesnt do it for me, playin ugly ogre face, besides being ultra fat i dont see why she gets hyped so much imo

Underrated:
Jae - gets little to no attention since her Weight loss, has put out some pretty good Content since her Weight loss, still gets shit talked because she didnt eat herself to death...

>Lady Sublime - Ugh, this one brings me no pleasure.
I disagree with you here, i love that she "acts" in her Videos because she does it Flawless thats what makes her content peak to me, her looks is just perfect, always has this "iam dissapointed in you, Breadwinner Mistress look" on her face. I have a worship fetish in some way and this Woman is just perfect for me. The fantasy part is just 10/10 on her Content

>>89414 (OP)

>Overrated: Violet James - Killer body, just an overwhelmingly massive slab of fat...

I dont see where Violet is anywhere near "Overrated" rarely see her getting posted, just once in a goon someoney starts a Thread that dissappears faster than they wank,,,
Anyway, here are my picks:

Overrated:
BoBerry: Shes hot and deserves every attention she gets, but gooners praise her and her Content like its out of this world, even her VIP days, Shit was expensive as fuck for what you got in return... She always seemed like a Kardashian in the SSBBW Secene to me... like gooners would by her "bathwater" if she sold it... still 10/10 Model, just a bit overrated but i can see why

Queenyaayaa: Not many words for here, for me to like a woman in this fetish i need to find her attractive in some way... she just doesnt do it for me, playin ugly ogre face, besides being ultra fat i dont see why she gets hyped so much imo

Underrated:
Jae - gets little to no attention since her Weight loss, has put out some pretty good Content since her Weight loss, still gets shit talked because she didnt eat herself to death...

>Lady Sublime - Ugh, this one brings me no pleasure.
I disagree with you here, i love that she "acts" in her Videos because she does it Flawless thats what makes her content peak to me, her looks is just perfect, always has this "iam dissapointed in you, Breadwinner Mistress look" on her face. I have a worship fetish in some way and this Woman is just perfect for me. The fantasy part is just 10/10 on her Content

>>89595
>>89621
Echo is far from overrated and given how big she got and how much content we got from her, she is almost underrated.
It sounds like you aren’t a fan, rather than she’s overrated as such.
I’m a fan of the blobbier side of USSBBW I must admit, and Echo is up there as one of the best (Patty is still #1 for me though)

Who would you say are the more lucid SSBBW’s then?

>>89629
Gotta chime in here to say that Yaayaa is one of the GOATs. I do think she's cute, but besides that she can eat so much food so fast, moreso than virtually any other model I've seen. She's put on a hundred pounds in the past couple years when she was already enormous and is within spitting distance of 700lbs at the age of 27. Her videos might not be to your personal taste, but IMO she is one of the greats.

>>89629
Calling Jae underrated is straight up diabolical. I almost have to respect the audacity, it's so contrarian. For the record, people don't care that she didn't want to "eat herself to death" we care that she shit all over the fetish and blamed it for all her problems and took zero responsibility for her life. It's kinda hard to respect people who refuse accountability. Regardless of her personal life, her content now is S H I T E . Anyone who buys her new "jae moonbeam" videos on c4s, and support that shit, are doing more damage to this fetish than ozempic ever will. The more money she makes doing this crap the more other models will follow suit.

>>89648
Does anyone really give a fuck though or just the same couple of tards who take it as a personal insult if an internet whore got burnt out on the kink.

>>89637
I need to see her keep it up for a few more years before I start saying stuff like this but I can see the vision here. She has a chance to really carve out a name for herself with most of the other younger 700+ pound girls tapping out (Super Soft, Hayley, Miss T).

>>89648
Definitely agree which is why I stopped buying her content when she went rogue. She gets two thumbs way way down from me 👎🏻👎🏻

>>89567
Haha that Shar rant would get you bad from Simpvage.....sorry Curvage....

>>89691
I think Shar herself is likely confused by the sheer degree of worship she receives.

For me, the most underrated SSBBW has to be SSBBW Emma.

I love huge bellies but I don't want someone to be a Twinkiebelle level of a barely mobile hog (I say this despite 700lbs Adeline being my all time favourite SSBBW) and I've been a fan of Emma ever since I saw a video of her and Lisa Lou struggling to get into Lisa's car back when they were both blondes.

It really feels like Emma doesn't get the love that Lisa gets and I would love to see them reunite and continue to do videos together.

Maybe a third Enjoying Emma video?

>>89414 (OP)
ps2 rock band guitar hero algorithm